← All stories
TrustpilotVerifiedAugust 4, 2026

Reimbursement Required Repurchasing Items First; Several Were Irreplaceable

  • Missing/Stolen Items
  • Insufficient Coverage
  • Inadequate Investigation
Verification
Verified
The original post or complaint is linked and exists as described, and the core facts match the source.
Failure point
Corporate Policy/Claims Process
Company responded
Unknown
Resolution
Unresolved

A customer says several clothing items were lost during a Poplin order, and that Poplin acknowledged the loss but required the items be repurchased before reimbursement would be considered. Some of the missing items were handmade, discontinued, or purchased internationally, making repurchase impossible. The customer reported the issue immediately, provided item descriptions and values, followed up repeatedly over several weeks, and sent a formal escalation request, but says communication from the company eventually stopped entirely.

Had a similar experience? Submit your story or read what to do next. Think something here is inaccurate? Request a correction.